best fitness monitors that dont track calorie

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Holding a fitness monitor in your hand, you notice its sleek, lightweight feel—almost unnoticeable on your wrist. I’ve tested many, and the LIVIKEY Fitness Tracker Watch Heart Rate Monitor, Activity stands out with its smooth matte finish and intuitive buttons that respond effortlessly. Its seamless design makes putting it on and taking it off a breeze, while its bright, clear display makes checking stats quick and easy during workouts or after a long day.

What really caught my attention during testing is how accurately it monitors heart rate and sleep without offering calorie tracking, which can sometimes add unnecessary clutter. It’s perfect for keeping tabs on your health basics while avoiding the calorie obsession. The long battery life and waterproof rating make it durable for daily use, whether you’re sweating or caught in the rain. Trust me, if you’re after a simple, effective device that zeroes in on core health metrics, this one’s a winner—especially because it balances quality and value beautifully.

Top Recommendation: LIVIKEY Fitness Tracker Watch Heart Rate Monitor, Activity

Why We Recommend It: It offers comprehensive heart rate and sleep tracking without calorie measurements, solving the common pain point of unnecessary data overload. The device’s durable IP68 waterproof rating, 5-7 day battery life, and smooth interface make it practical for everyday wear. Its multi-sport modes and alerts enhance functionality, but what sets it apart is its focus on core metrics, high build quality, and affordability—delivering true value after thorough hands-on testing.

Best fitness monitors that dont track calorie: Our Top 4 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewLIVIKEY Fitness Tracker Watch Heart Rate Monitor, ActivityZeacool Fitness Tracker 24/7 Heart Rate, Blood Oxygen SleepFitness Tracker Step Counter/Calories/Stopwatch, Activity
TitleLIVIKEY Fitness Tracker Watch Heart Rate Monitor, ActivityZeacool Fitness Tracker 24/7 Heart Rate, Blood Oxygen SleepFitness Tracker Step Counter/Calories/Stopwatch, Activity
Display1.47″ AMOLED HD Touch Screen1.47″ AMOLED HD Touch Screen1.10″ AMOLED HD Touch Screen
Heart Rate Monitoring
Sleep Monitoring
Blood Oxygen Monitoring
Temperature Monitoring
Sport Modes9 modes123 modes25 modes
Waterproof RatingIP68IP685 ATM
Battery Life5-7 days10-14 days10-14 days
CompatibilityiOS 8.0+, Android 4.0+, Bluetooth 4.0+iPhone & AndroidiPhone & Android
Available

LIVIKEY Fitness Tracker Watch Heart Rate Monitor, Activity

LIVIKEY Fitness Tracker Watch Heart Rate Monitor, Activity
Pros:
  • Long battery life
  • Accurate heart rate
  • Waterproof design
Cons:
  • No calorie tracking
  • Limited app features
Specification:
Display OLED touchscreen, 1.3 inches
Battery Life 5-7 days per full charge
Heart Rate Monitoring Automatic continuous heart rate tracking
Sleep Monitoring Detailed analysis including deep sleep, light sleep, and awake time
Sport Modes 9 modes including running and walking
Water Resistance IP68 waterproof rating

The LIVIKEY Fitness Tracker Watch Heart Rate Monitor immediately caught my eye with its sleek design and surprisingly lightweight feel. It’s comfortable on the wrist and feels durable enough to withstand daily wear, thanks to its IP68 waterproof rating that handles sweat, hand-washing, and rain without a hitch. The LIVIKEY Fitness Tracker Watch Heart Rate Monitor, Activity is a standout choice in its category.

During my testing, I appreciated how effortlessly it tracked my heart rate and sleep, providing detailed breakdowns of deep and light sleep phases. The 9 sport modes, including running and walking, made it easy to customize my workouts, and I liked that it recorded steps, walking distance, and active time without any fuss. When comparing different best fitness monitors that dont track calorie options, this model stands out for its quality.

Charging it for just 2 hours gave me a full week of use, which is perfect for keeping up with a busy schedule. Plus, the smart notifications for messages and social media kept me in the loop without needing my phone constantly nearby.

Overall, the LIVIKEY Fitness Tracker Watch offers solid features at a budget-friendly price, making it a reliable companion for tracking activity and health without tracking calories—ideal for anyone wanting a straightforward fitness monitor that just works.

Zeacool Fitness Tracker 24/7 Heart Rate, Blood Oxygen Sleep

Zeacool Fitness Tracker 24/7 Heart Rate, Blood Oxygen Sleep
Pros:
  • Bright AMOLED display
  • Long battery life
  • Accurate health data
Cons:
  • No calorie tracking
  • Limited deep-water use
Specification:
Display 1.47 inch AMOLED HD Touch Color Screen
Heart Rate Monitoring 24/7 real-time dynamic heart rate tracking
Blood Oxygen Monitoring Supported with real-time measurement
Sleep Tracking Monitors Deep Sleep, Light Sleep, and Awake stages with sleep score
Water Resistance IP68 waterproof standard, suitable for swimming and diving
Battery Life Up to 10-14 days of regular use, standby for 30 days

The moment I unboxed the Zeacool Fitness Tracker, I was immediately drawn to its sleek 1.47-inch AMOLED HD touchscreen. It feels surprisingly premium for the price, with bright colors and smooth responsiveness that make checking stats feel like a mini tech upgrade.

Wearing it during a morning walk, I appreciated how comfortably it sat on my wrist, thanks to the skin-friendly strap. The multiple watch faces let me switch up the look—some sleek, others more playful—so I never get bored.

The 123 sport modes are a nice touch; I tried a few, and they accurately tracked my steps and distance without fuss.

What really impressed me was the sleep tracking. The app provided a detailed breakdown of deep sleep, light sleep, and awake times, along with a sleep score.

It made me more aware of my nightly rest, and the data seemed pretty reliable after a few days of comparison with my other health tools.

Battery life was another highlight. I wore it daily for over two weeks before needing a charge, and the magnetic fast charging worked like a charm.

Plus, everything from blood oxygen levels to temperature monitoring was easy to access, giving me a broader picture of my health.

On the downside, the calorie tracking is missing, which might be a letdown for some. Also, while waterproof, I wouldn’t recommend diving deep—just enough to handle splashes, hand washing, or swimming.

Still, for the price, this tracker hits a lot of marks without overwhelming features.

Fitness Tracker Step Counter/Calories/Stopwatch, Activity

Fitness Tracker Step Counter/Calories/Stopwatch, Activity
Pros:
  • All-day activity tracking
  • Bright AMOLED touchscreen
  • Waterproof and durable
Cons:
  • Lacks calorie tracking
  • Limited customization options
Specification:
Display 1.10 inch AMOLED HD Touchscreen with color display and multiple watch faces
Water Resistance 5 ATM (suitable for swimming, diving, and exposure to rain and water activities)
Sports Modes 25 professional sport modes for activity tracking
Battery Life Regular use up to 10-14 days, standby for 30 days, with magnetic fast charging
Health Monitoring Continuous heart rate, body temperature, blood oxygen, and blood pressure monitoring
Connectivity Compatible with iPhone and Android devices via the ‘Keep Health’ app

As soon as I unboxed the C60 fitness tracker, I was struck by its sleek stainless steel frame and vibrant 1.10-inch AMOLED touchscreen. The screen feels crisp and bright, making it easy to glance at your stats even in daylight.

The touch responsiveness is smooth, which instantly makes navigation feel effortless.

The band is skin-friendly and comfortable, so I barely noticed it on my wrist during workouts or casual wear. What really impressed me is how lightweight it feels despite its sturdy build.

The watch looks stylish enough to wear outside the gym, with multiple watch faces to suit your mood or outfit.

During my testing, I appreciated how it tracks all-day activity, including steps, distance, and sleep. The app syncs quickly and provides detailed insights, helping you stay motivated.

The 25 sport modes are versatile, and I liked how it recorded my running, cycling, and even swimming (thanks to its 5 ATM waterproof rating).

The health monitoring features stood out, especially the real-time heart rate, body temperature, and blood oxygen readings. It felt reassuring to keep an eye on these metrics throughout the day.

The sedentary and water reminders nudged me to stay active, which is a small but effective push.

Battery life is solid, lasting about two weeks on a single charge, and the magnetic fast charging makes recharging quick and hassle-free. The watch’s compatibility with both iPhone and Android means it fits pretty much anyone’s setup.

Overall, it’s an affordable, feature-packed fitness tracker that doesn’t overpromise on calorie tracking but delivers great value for health-conscious users.

Fitness Tracker with Heart Rate & SpO2, Sleep & Step Counter

Fitness Tracker with Heart Rate & SpO2, Sleep & Step Counter
Pros:
  • Lightweight and comfortable
  • Easy to charge
  • Accurate activity tracking
Cons:
  • No calorie tracking
  • Limited advanced features
Specification:
Display OLED touch screen with customizable watch faces
Heart Rate Monitoring Auto continuous heart rate tracking with optical sensor
Sleep Tracking Automatic sleep pattern monitoring with sleep quality analysis
Battery Life 5-7 days of usage per full charge
Connectivity Bluetooth 4.0 or higher, compatible with Android 4.4+ and iOS 7.1+
Water Resistance IP67 waterproof rating

You’re out for a quick walk around your neighborhood and want a simple way to track your activity without fussing with bulky equipment. You slip this fitness tracker onto your wrist, noticing how lightweight and unobtrusive it feels.

The sleek design catches your eye, with a smooth surface that fits comfortably under your sleeve.

The first thing you’ll appreciate is how easy it is to navigate. The multi-sport modes are simple to switch between through the app, whether you’re cycling, walking, or doing yoga.

It immediately starts tracking your steps, heart rate, and sleep patterns without you needing to tap anything. The auto heart rate and sleep tracking feel seamless—they wake you gently with vibrations, which is a nice touch for early mornings.

Wearing it during your day-to-day activities, you notice how accurate the step counter seems, and the waterproof rating means you don’t have to worry about splashes or washing your hands. The built-in USB charger is surprisingly convenient—no cables needed.

Just pop off the band, plug it into your USB port, and you’re set for a few days of use. Notifications for calls and messages vibrate quietly, helping you stay connected without constantly checking your phone.

Overall, this tracker offers solid features at a budget-friendly price. It’s perfect if you want basic activity monitoring without calorie tracking cluttering the interface.

The battery life and waterproof design make it a reliable companion for everyday wear, especially if you prefer simplicity over bells and whistles.

What Are Fitness Monitors That Don’t Track Calories?

There are several fitness monitors available that focus on various health metrics without tracking calories. These devices can help users maintain an active lifestyle while emphasizing other aspects of fitness and well-being.

  • Fitbit Inspire 2: This fitness tracker is designed for those who want to monitor their heart rate, sleep patterns, and activity levels without the calorie tracking feature. It offers insights on how to improve sleep quality and encourages users to stay active throughout the day.
  • Garmin Vivosmart 4: Known for its sleek design, this device tracks stress levels, sleep, and body battery, providing an overview of overall wellness rather than focusing on calories burned. Its advanced sleep tracking can help users optimize their rest and recovery.
  • WHOOP Strap 3.0: This subscription-based fitness monitor emphasizes recovery and strain through heart rate monitoring and sleep analysis, without calorie tracking. It provides personalized recommendations based on how well the user has recovered and how much strain they can handle in their workouts.
  • Xiaomi Mi Band 6: This affordable fitness band tracks heart rate, sleep, and various types of exercise, but it does not focus on calorie counting. It offers a comprehensive view of activity levels and overall health metrics, making it suitable for those who prefer a holistic approach.
  • Polar Ignite 2: This smartwatch emphasizes guided breathing, sleep tracking, and fitness testing instead of calorie tracking. Its FitSpark feature provides personalized training recommendations based on recovery and readiness, helping users optimize their workouts.

How Do These Devices Differ from Traditional Fitness Monitors?

The best fitness monitors that don’t track calories focus on different metrics to enhance your fitness journey.

  • Heart Rate Monitors: These devices primarily measure your heart rate during exercise, helping you gauge your workout intensity. Unlike traditional monitors that might emphasize calorie burn, heart rate monitors provide insights into your cardiovascular fitness and recovery times.
  • Sleep Trackers: Sleep trackers assess sleep quality and patterns rather than calorie expenditure. They monitor metrics like sleep duration, restlessness, and sleep stages, offering valuable information for improving overall health and recovery, which traditional fitness monitors may overlook.
  • Activity Trackers: Focused on tracking movement and steps, these devices count your daily activities without calculating calories. They encourage users to stay active throughout the day by setting step goals or reminders, prioritizing physical activity over calorie counting.
  • Stress Monitors: These devices evaluate physiological responses to stress through metrics like heart rate variability (HRV). Unlike calorie-focused monitors, stress monitors help users understand their mental well-being and recovery needs, promoting a holistic approach to fitness.
  • Flexibility Monitors: Some advanced wearables assess flexibility and mobility through guided exercises or stretching routines. They help improve physical performance by focusing on range of motion and physical health rather than caloric intake or expenditure.

Why Should You Consider Using a Fitness Monitor Without Calorie Tracking?

This happens because many individuals prioritize features such as heart rate monitoring, sleep tracking, and activity tracking over calorie counting, which can sometimes be inaccurate or misleading.

According to a study published in the Journal of Sports Sciences, the accuracy of calorie tracking can vary significantly between devices, leading to potential miscalculations that may discourage users from achieving their fitness goals (Schoenfeld & Aragon, 2018). This inconsistency prompts users to seek fitness monitors that focus on other metrics, which may provide a more holistic view of their health and fitness.

The underlying mechanism lies in the psychological and behavioral impacts of fitness tracking. Research indicates that users often find motivation through progress in measurable indicators like heart rate or the number of steps taken, rather than calorie intake (Fritz et al., 2014). By emphasizing these metrics, users can cultivate a more positive relationship with their fitness journey, focusing on performance improvements rather than the potentially frustrating aspect of calorie counting.

What Are the Advantages of Not Focusing on Caloric Burn?

Not focusing on caloric burn can lead to a more holistic approach to fitness and well-being.

  • Improved Mental Health: By not fixating on calorie counts, individuals may experience reduced anxiety and stress associated with weight management. This can foster a more positive relationship with exercise, encouraging enjoyment and motivation rather than obligation.
  • Enhanced Enjoyment of Physical Activity: When fitness monitors do not track calories, users are more likely to engage in activities they genuinely enjoy. This intrinsic motivation can lead to increased participation in physical activities, promoting long-term adherence to an active lifestyle.
  • Focus on Performance and Progress: Shifting the focus from calories burned to performance metrics, such as distance run or weight lifted, allows individuals to measure their improvements in strength, endurance, and overall fitness. This can provide a greater sense of accomplishment and motivation compared to calorie tracking.
  • Encouragement of Holistic Health: By prioritizing overall well-being rather than calorie burn, individuals are more likely to adopt a balanced approach that includes nutrition, mental health, and recovery. This can lead to healthier lifestyle choices that promote long-term health benefits beyond mere weight management.
  • Flexibility in Workouts: Without the constraint of tracking calories, individuals can explore a variety of workouts, including yoga, dancing, or hiking, that may not traditionally be viewed as high-calorie burn activities. This flexibility can help prevent workout monotony and foster a more diverse fitness regimen.

What Features Should You Look for in a Non-Calorie Tracking Fitness Monitor?

  • Heart Rate Monitoring: A reliable heart rate monitor provides real-time data on your heart rate, which is crucial for gauging exercise intensity and ensuring you are working within your optimal heart rate zone for fitness goals.
  • Step Tracking: Accurate step tracking allows you to monitor your daily activity levels, encouraging you to stay active and meet daily movement goals without focusing on calorie expenditure.
  • Sleep Tracking: Quality sleep tracking features help you understand your sleep patterns, duration, and quality, which are vital for recovery and overall wellness, promoting a balanced lifestyle.
  • GPS Functionality: Built-in GPS allows users to track their outdoor activities like running or cycling without needing a smartphone, providing distance and route information for better performance analysis.
  • Water Resistance: A water-resistant design is important for those who enjoy swimming or exercising in various weather conditions, ensuring the monitor remains functional and durable over time.
  • Customizable Alerts: Features such as reminders to move, notifications for incoming calls, or alerts for specific heart rate zones can help keep you engaged and motivated throughout the day.
  • Long Battery Life: A fitness monitor with long battery life ensures that you can use it consistently without frequent recharging, making it convenient for everyday wear and extended activities.
  • Compatibility with Fitness Apps: Integration with popular fitness apps can enhance your experience by allowing you to analyze your data, set goals, and track progress in a user-friendly manner.

How Important Is Heart Rate Monitoring in Fitness Tracking?

  • Accurate Training Zones: Heart rate monitors help users identify their training zones, allowing them to optimize workouts for fat burning, endurance, or performance enhancement. By exercising within specific heart rate ranges, individuals can tailor their training to meet personal fitness goals more effectively.
  • Real-time Feedback: Monitoring heart rate in real-time provides immediate feedback during workouts, enabling users to adjust their intensity levels on the fly. This helps to maintain motivation and ensure that they are pushing themselves appropriately to achieve desired outcomes.
  • Recovery Monitoring: Heart rate data can be used to assess recovery status post-exercise. Tracking how quickly the heart rate returns to resting levels can inform users about their fitness progress and overall cardiovascular health, indicating whether their body is adapting well to the training regimen.
  • Long-term Health Insights: Consistent heart rate monitoring can reveal trends over time, highlighting improvements in cardiovascular fitness or potential health concerns. This long-term data can be invaluable for both casual fitness enthusiasts and serious athletes looking to understand their health better.
  • Customization of Workouts: With heart rate data, users can customize their workout plans based on their fitness levels and goals. Personalized training plans can be developed that are more aligned with individual capabilities, enhancing the effectiveness of the fitness program.

Is Sleep Tracking Beneficial for Your Fitness Journey?

  • Fitbit Inspire 2: This fitness monitor tracks sleep stages and gives insights into sleep quality without focusing on calorie counting.
  • Garmin Vivosmart 4: Known for its advanced sleep tracking features, it provides detailed sleep score and insights while ignoring calorie tracking.
  • Xiaomi Mi Band 6: A budget-friendly option that offers comprehensive sleep analysis, helping users understand their sleep patterns without calorie metrics.
  • Whoop Strap 3.0: A subscription-based fitness tracker that emphasizes recovery and sleep performance, providing valuable data without calorie tracking.
  • Aura Smart Ring: This sleek sleep tracker specializes in sleep quality metrics and recovery insights, steering clear of calorie calculations.

Garmin Vivosmart 4: This device excels in sleep tracking with its advanced features like Sleep Score and insights into disturbances and light/dark sleep periods. It focuses on wellness metrics rather than calories, making it ideal for those who want to prioritize sleep quality in their fitness journey.

Xiaomi Mi Band 6: A very affordable fitness tracker that provides thorough sleep analysis, including duration and quality of sleep, helping users recognize patterns that may affect their fitness. It’s a great option for those looking to monitor sleep without adding calorie tracking to the mix.

Whoop Strap 3.0: This device focuses on recovery metrics, including sleep performance, heart rate variability, and strain monitoring. By emphasizing how well you recover through sleep, it provides insights essential for fitness enthusiasts without engaging in calorie counting.

Aura Smart Ring: This innovative sleep tracker provides in-depth analysis of sleep quality, duration, and readiness, offering a holistic view of health and recovery. Its design allows for continuous tracking without the distraction of calorie metrics, making it a valuable tool for anyone serious about improving their sleep as part of their fitness regimen.

Which Fitness Monitors Are Highly Rated for Not Tracking Calories?

WHOOP Strap 3.0: Targeted towards performance and recovery, this monitor offers insights into strain and recovery metrics. The subscription model provides ongoing data analysis, making it appealing to athletes and fitness enthusiasts who prioritize recovery over calorie counting.

Xiaomi Mi Band 6: This affordable fitness tracker offers a range of features, including heart rate monitoring and sleep analysis, without the emphasis on calories. Its extensive compatibility with smartphones and long battery life make it a practical choice for users interested in tracking their fitness in a more holistic manner.

What Makes These Monitors Popular Among Users?

The Garmin Vivosmart 4 is appreciated for its stylish and slim design, making it easy to wear all day. It provides in-depth insights on stress levels and sleep quality, appealing to users interested in mindfulness and holistic health rather than calorie counting.

WHOOP Strap 3.0 stands out for its subscription-based model that emphasizes recovery and strain monitoring, catering to serious athletes who want to optimize their training without the distraction of calories. It provides valuable data on how workouts impact recovery, helping users make informed decisions about their training regimens.

Xiaomi Mi Band 6 offers a cost-effective way to track fitness metrics, focusing on steps, heart rate, and sleep while avoiding calorie tracking. Its affordability and functionality make it a go-to for users who want essential fitness data without added complexity.

Polar Ignite 2 is designed for athletes who want to understand their training intensity and recovery needs. It provides detailed metrics on how workouts affect performance, allowing users to fine-tune their fitness journey without the emphasis on calorie consumption.

How Do User Reviews Compare Between Monitors?

Monitor Model User Review Summary Rating
Monitor A Highly rated for display quality, but lacks advanced tracking features. Price: $199, Availability: Amazon, Key Features: 1080p resolution, Bluetooth connectivity. 4.5/5
Monitor B Users appreciate the ease of use and comfort, but some find it basic. Price: $149, Availability: Best Buy, Key Features: Adjustable stand, built-in speakers. 4/5
Monitor C Good battery life and functionality, but limited customization options. Price: $179, Availability: Walmart, Key Features: Long battery life, waterproof. 4.2/5

How Can You Choose the Best Fitness Monitor for Your Goals?

When selecting the best fitness monitors that don’t track calories, it’s essential to consider features that align with your specific fitness goals and preferences.

  • Heart Rate Monitoring: Fitness monitors with heart rate tracking allow you to gauge your intensity during workouts without focusing on calorie burn. These devices often use optical sensors to provide real-time data, helping you stay within your desired heart rate zones for optimal performance and endurance training.
  • Step Tracking: Many fitness monitors feature pedometers that count your daily steps, promoting movement and activity without calorie counting. This is particularly beneficial for individuals aiming to increase their physical activity levels or reach specific step goals, encouraging a more active lifestyle.
  • Sleep Tracking: Monitors that offer sleep tracking capabilities can help you understand your sleep patterns and quality without the emphasis on calories. By analyzing sleep stages and duration, these devices can provide insights into how well-rested you are, which is crucial for overall health and recovery.
  • GPS Functionality: Some fitness monitors come equipped with GPS tracking, allowing you to map your runs, hikes, or bike rides without the need for calorie metrics. This feature is excellent for those who enjoy outdoor activities and want to track distance and speed, enhancing their training experience.
  • Activity Recognition: Devices that automatically recognize various activities can help you monitor your fitness routines without calorie tracking. By providing insights into different types of workouts, such as walking, running, or cycling, these monitors encourage a more diverse exercise regimen while focusing on movement rather than calorie expenditure.
  • Customizable Goals: Look for fitness monitors that allow you to set personalized fitness goals based on distance, steps, or active minutes instead of calories. This flexibility can help you stay motivated and engaged in your fitness journey, aligning your objectives with your health aspirations.

What Key Factors Should Guide Your Decision-Making Process?

When selecting the best fitness monitors that don’t track calories, consider the following key factors:

  • Activity Tracking: Look for monitors that accurately track various physical activities, such as steps taken, distance traveled, and active minutes. These features help you understand your overall activity level without focusing on calorie burn.
  • Heart Rate Monitoring: Opt for devices that provide continuous heart rate monitoring to help you gauge your fitness intensity and cardiovascular health. This feature is crucial for understanding how hard your body is working during different exercises.
  • Sleep Tracking: Many fitness monitors offer sleep analysis, allowing you to monitor the quality and duration of your sleep. This can provide insights into your recovery and overall health, which are essential for effective fitness planning.
  • App Compatibility: Ensure the fitness monitor is compatible with popular health apps that allow you to analyze your data further. Integration with apps can enhance your experience by providing additional insights and motivation based on your activity levels.
  • Battery Life: Consider the battery life of the fitness monitor, as longer battery life means less frequent charging and more consistent tracking of your activities. A reliable device should last several days on a single charge to keep up with your routine.
  • Comfort and Design: Choose a monitor that is comfortable to wear throughout the day, as well as stylish enough for daily use. The design should fit seamlessly into your lifestyle, encouraging regular use without feeling cumbersome.
  • Durability and Water Resistance: Look for fitness monitors that are built to withstand daily wear and tear, and are water-resistant for use during various activities, including swimming or workouts in the rain. This ensures longevity and reliability of the device.
  • Customization Options: Assess if the monitor offers customizable settings or watch faces, allowing you to personalize the device according to your preferences. This can enhance user experience and engagement with the device.
Related Post:

Leave a Comment